Extract: Trading Blows, by Matthew Wright
The period of early European contact with Maori from 1806 to 1845 has come to be known as the Musket Wars. But as Matthew Wright writes, there were many factors besides muskets at play in the to-and-fro of utu (revenge) that ravaged Maori society, causing death and displacement on a massive scale. Analysing the full range of battles that erupted with early settling of scores by Hongi Hika and Ngapuhi in the Far North, and extended deep into the South Island through the ruthless campaigns of Te Rauparaha, Trading Blows investigates what lay at their cause. As such it is not a military history, but focuses on the far-reaching social changes driven by an economic revolution.
.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
Extracted with kind permission from Trading Blows: What Drove the Musket Wars by Matthew Wright (Oratia Books, Auckland, 2026; ISBN 9781991353023, 224 pages, $45)
In the decades before the Treaty of Waitangi, Māori fought each other on an unprecedented scale. War parties surged the length of the country. Traditional occupations were turned upside down as iwi migrated. Warfare had always been an accompaniment to life in New Zealand, as it was to most human societies. But now it surged to new intensity, sometimes fought across what later became domestic backyards, and it exposed the human condition in all its terrible, vast, heroic, tragic and emotional depth. Although defying the sharp beginnings and endings beloved of Pākehā history, around 500 engagements were fought from the beginning of the wars in the late 1810s, through to their ragged end in the early 1840s. In some places the bones of the dead were left bleaching on the battlefields, interred a generation later by Pākehā settlers.
These dramatic events became known as the ‘musket wars’, after the small-arm mostprominently used by Māori of the day. The conflicts of the period have also been described as the ‘forgotten wars’ of New Zealand, little studied despite their direct influence on New Zealand’s present. The locations of major centres, including Auckland, Wellington, New Plymouth and others, all derive from the outcomes of these early nineteenth-century conflicts. Initial land acquisitions by the New Zealand Company, and later the government land purchase programmes of the 1840s, often ran roughshod across the profound dislocations that the wars of the contact period produced in traditional land-holding, creating issues that in some cases still remain unaddressed. These wars, in short, fundamentally shaped modern New Zealand physically and politically, feeding into race- relations and carrying a very real legacy that makes them relevant today.
In a way it is unsurprising that thinking about the dramatic events of the early nineteenth century has been largely ‘snap frozen’ around a nineteenth-century narrative of guns and savagery. New Zealand’s view of its history has been shaped by what we might call the tyranny of 1840: the division into ‘before’ and ‘after’ the moment when Britain formally established New Zealand as a colony. The ‘before’ has attracted far less attention. One result has been that despite an unprecedented renewal of interest in New Zealand history since the 1980s, our vision of the remarkable cycle of pre-Treaty warfare that erupted from the early nineteenth century remains largely framed by the 1890s–1910s ‘recovery narratives’ of Stephenson Percy Smith and his contemporaries. These entrenched the notion of immediate pre-Treaty decades defined by muskets and fighting, a vision that engaged period stereotypes of indigenous people as savages. Even the original settler-era name has stuck, although as we will see in this book ‘musket wars’ is not a particularly useful term for a dynamic period in which the musket was not widespread until surprisingly late in the process.
Very little has been written to explain why these events occurred. How did these wars fit into the contact process? What drove them? And were they really about any of the many types of British weapons Māori procured, including cannons? Recent academic study has been minimal — just two theses since the 1990s, both heavily framed by the colonial-era focus on weaponry, and one peer-reviewed paper. A handful of books were published between the 1980s and the first years of the twenty-first century. All revolved around the concept of an era defined by muskets and the warfare that followed. One exception was Angela Ballara’s Taua of 2003, which attempted to intellectualise the wars out of existence altogether, viewing them as an illusion generated by settler-era misunderstanding of normal Māori politics.
[In Trading Blows my intent is to show that these events were symptomatic of a Maori economic revolution.] Access to the full range of British goods and technologies transformed the Māori labour calculation, creating a social and economic shockwave. This was not surprising: British society itself had responded in similarly dramatic fashion to the social and economic shock provoked when mechanised industry transformed their own production base a generation or so earlier.
The impacts on the British and on Māori — in one case, of industrialisation and in the other of the introduction of industrial products — created heavy strains across wide sectors of each society, and understandably so. In each case the result was filtered through the frameworks of the societies involved. In Britain, a centrally-governed nation, industrialisation impoverished layers of society, and one outcome was street violence and riots. In New Zealand, where Māori were independent iwi, and where warfare was part of a continuum of ways in which they interacted, one result was intensified war.
If we look at the New Zealand experience from this social and economic perspective it becomes clear that the popular term ‘musket wars’ is a misnomer. Once we dig beneath the surface we find that this British small-arm neither defined nor drove the period. This book should accordingly not be mistaken for a military history. It is intended to explore some of the broad shapes and patterns of the main socio- economic forces underpinning the wars, not to narrate every expedition and battle. Warfare, as we shall explore, was one of the outcomes of a wide-based collision between the products of a relatively new British economic system and precontact Māori culture. Small-arms such as muskets, along with the cannons that Māori obtained from the late 1820s, were symptoms of change, not causes.
The story of the full impact of British industrial technology on early nineteenth-century Māori deserves a book of its own: my aim here has been to explore enough of it to show that the dramatic events of the contact period were more nuanced than history has allowed.
History, as a field of endeavour and study, is primarily about understanding the human condition through time, of finding the differences between past and present, and of exploring a journey of change. Nuance and the interplays of multiple factors inevitably intrude, meaning that explanations cannot be reduced to eight-word sound bites. It also means that history is a discussion, one in which dissent from one view is not the same as advocating the position that such a view demonises. Human reality is complex, multifaceted, and the narrative chronology often only a symptom of deeper forces. The tools for understanding — the creations of Karl Popper, among others — draw from the philosophy of the sciences and anthropology as much as history. And the first step is to accept that the past is a foreign land. It was often not a nice place, and certainly will not coordinate with current ideals. This does not mean approval. Equally, historians should not try to intellectualise past realities into something that meets contemporary ideology. Shared ideas, language and ancestry offer only an illusory sense of familiarity: the past is in truth another country.
There is also an assumption, certainly at popular level, that history is a quest for objective ‘final’ answers. This was one focus of New Zealand’s first generation of historians in the 1890s, and has emerged since in enthusiast works that reduce the past to uncritically assembled lists of data. This idea sometimes appears even within the academy as a device for straw-man denial of worth. In practice the nature of available data limits answers, and in any case, the broader social shapes and patterns are such that any analysis must by nature be a discussion. In this regard even the largest book can cover only aspects of a topic. For these reasons, this book does not recount all the narrative detail of the wars. This is available in other publications, some reproduced online.
The point gains perspective when we consider the dates relating to the musket wars, all of which must be taken with grains of salt. Some events were observed by the British, often with specific dates attached. Others were not, and what counted in the Māori oral record were precedents. That jarred with settler priorities. ‘I have found considerable difficulty in fixing the exact dates,’ the Reverend James Stack bemoaned of his musket wars writings in 1892. Late settler-age historians such as Smith put a good deal of over-rational enthusiasm into their chronologies. This was a symptom of the imposition of colonial values on the Māori oral record.
Trading Blows is available in all good bookstores now.


